Corporation for National and Community Service
I
R
NDIVIDUAL
EVIEWER FORM
2015 FGP-SCP I
T
C
NDIAN
RIBES
OMPETITION
Legal Applicant:
Application ID:
Reviewer Name:
Assess the extent to which the applicant addresses each of the Criteria. Using the reviewer rubric as a guide to
understanding the ratings, select a rating to show how well the application addresses each criterion element.
I. Program Design (50%)
Strengthening Communities and Performance Measures Work Plans‐ Questions 1‐4
Recruitment and Development of Volunteers‐ Questions 5‐8
Strengthening Communities (35%)
Q1. Describes the community and demonstrates that the community need(s) identified in the Primary Focus Area of
Education (FGP) or Healthy Futures‐ Independent Living and/or Respite for Caregivers (SCP) exist in the geographic
service area.
Provides persuasive evidence identifying the community need that is a high
__Excellent
(7 pts.)
priority for the geographic service area, using objective data and evidence,
or statements of support from key stakeholders.
Goes beyond what was requested; shows that meeting this need is
a high priority for the geographic service area.
Provides a thorough, detailed response to all of the information
requested.
Provides a clear and highly compelling description of the
community need.
Supports assertion of a high priority community need with
statements of support from key stakeholders.
Demonstrates a community need in the geographic service area using
__Good
(5 pts.)
objective data.
Provides a response to all of the information requested.
Explains most assumptions that the community need exists
Supports assertion of community need with examples or other
objective data.
Demonstrates a community need in the geographic service area using
__Fair
(3 pts.)
objective data.
Describes a community need but the objective data does not
clearly provide persuasive evidence to demonstrate the community
need.
Describes a community need but makes some assumptions that the
community need exists in the geographic service area.
Does not provide any objective sources in describing a community need in
__Does Not Meet
(0 pts.)
the geographic service area.
Gives many unsupported assumptions and reasons that the issue
described is a community need.
Makes many assumptions that the community need exists in the
geographic service area.
Tends to “parrot” back the question, rather than answer and
explain it.
Does not respond with any objective data.
1