Appendix C - Evaluation Forms - General Project Evaluation Form printable pdf download

Appendix C - Evaluation Forms - General Project Evaluation Form

APPENDIX C: EVALUATION FORMS

General Project Evaluation Form

This evaluation form was used for the following sub-program panels: Hydrogen Production and Delivery; Hydrogen

Storage; Fuel Cells; Manufacturing R&D; Safety, Codes and Standards; Education; Market Transformation;

Technology Validation; and Systems Analysis.

PeerNet Evaluation Criteria: General Evaluation Form

Provide specific, concise comments to support your evaluation. Please write clearly.

1. Relevance

To overall DOE objectives – the degree to which the project supports the Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Program and the

goals and objectives in the Multi-Year Research, Development, and Demonstration (RD&D) Plan. (Weight = 20%)

4 - Outstanding. Project is critical to the Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Program and fully supports DOE RD&D

objectives.

3 - Good. Most project aspects align with the Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Program and DOE RD&D objectives.

2 - Fair. Project partially supports the Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Program and DOE RD&D objectives.

1 - Poor. Project provides little support to the Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Program and DOE RD&D objectives.

4 - Outstanding

3 - Good

2 - Fair

1 - Poor

Comments on relevance to overall DOE objectives:

2. Approach

To performing the work – the degree to which barriers are addressed, the project is well designed, feasible, and

integrated with other efforts. (Weight = 20%)

4 - Outstanding. Sharply focused on critical barriers; difficult to improve approach significantly.

3 - Good. Generally effective but could be improved; contributes to overcoming some barriers.

2 - Fair. Has significant weaknesses; may have some impact on overcoming barriers.

1 - Poor. Not responsive to project objectives; unlikely to contribute to overcoming the barriers.

4 - Outstanding

3 - Good

2 - Fair

1 - Poor

Comments on approach to performing the work:

849

FY 2011 Merit Review and Peer Evaluation Report

Appendix C - Evaluation Forms - General Project Evaluation Form