Synthesis Essay Peer Review Form
ADVERTISEMENT
1
2Synthesis Essay Peer Review
(Sample provided for 2011 Summer Symposium)
Writer: _____________________
Reviewer 1: _____________________
Reviewer 2: _____________________
Does the “writer” have a draft?
Y or N Y or N
Introduction
Are all authors and articles introduced?
Y or N Y or N
Is a brief summary of the each essay provided?
Y or N Y or N
(the main point(s) and, perhaps, some of the following info:
brief description of the author, info about the intended audience,
info about the context and purpose of the essay, possibly a quote
to give personality)
Is a clearly stated thesis provided?
Y or N Y or N
(the thesis should denote the type of synthesis – argumentative,
explanatory or compare and contrast)
Comments:
Body (Synthesis – this portion will vary depending upon the type of synthesis)
Is a supporting reason (an aspect of the synthesis that ties to the thesis) clearly discussed?
Y or N Y or N
Is information from essay A provided?
Y or N Y or N
Is information from essay B provided?
Y or N Y or N
nd
Is a 2
supporting reason (an aspect of the synthesis that ties to the thesis) clearly discussed?
Y or N Y or N
Is information from essay A provided?
Y or N Y or N
Is information from essay B provided?
Y or N Y or N
rd
Is a 3
supporting reason (an aspect of the synthesis that ties to the thesis) clearly discussed?
Y or N Y or N
Is information from essay A provided?
Y or N Y or N
Is information from essay B provided?
Y or N Y or N
Do all reasons and pieces of evidence tie back to the thesis?
Y or N Y or N
Comments:
Conclusion
Does the writer provide a memorable and concise conclusion?
Y or N Y or N
Comments:
Style and structure
Does the essay flow from sentence to sentence?
Y or N Y or N
Does the essay flow from paragraph to paragraph?
Y or N Y or N
Does the writer need to add in transitions?
Y or N Y or N
ADVERTISEMENT
0 votes
Related Articles
Related forms
Related Categories
Parent category: Business