Peer Review Form For A Seminar printable pdf download

Peer Review Form For A Seminar

Peer review form

Author (of thesis/proposal):

reviewer:

date:

date of meeting with peer:

Dear reviewer: please evaluate the thesis (proposal) by checking the appropriate boxes below and provide

more detailed comments in the space provided below the boxes. You can click the boxes and enter text with your keyboard and

finally print the form if you prefer.

The title is clear, compact and to the point, it contains all key identifiers of the (proposed) research.

deficient

good

outstanding

Comment:

The abstract introduces the topic and clearly describes the main (preliminary, i.a.) findings in a quantitative and space efficient

way.

deficient

good

outstanding

The introduction contains a compact but comprehensive presentation of background and prior work in the topic area starting broad

and narrowing to a clear thesis statement. It clearly defines the (proposed) research, and demonstrates student capacity to locate,

organize, analyze, integrate, synthesize, and evaluate complex information from multiple and disparate sources. Statements of fact

are always properly referenced.

deficient

good

outstanding

Analytical and quantitative (proposed) methods/approaches are selected adequately and presented comprehensively and

demonstrate creativity.

deficient

good

outstanding

(Preliminary) results are comprehensive and presented in a clear and organized fashion. Data analysis is appropriate and

exhaustive, including statistics where relevant.

deficient

good

outstanding

The discussion thoroughly interprets (preliminary) results in context of the thesis statement and properly cited studies. It fully and

creatively explores the topic and demonstrates capacity to organize, analyze, integrate, synthesize, and evaluate complex

1 of 2

3/2/2016 3:39 PM

Peer Review Form For A Seminar