Judging Score Card Template Page 3
ADVERTISEMENT
1
2
3
4Judge’s Name: __________________________________ Team Letter _________
Criteria
Excellent
Good
Fair
Below Average
Needs Improvement
Score
5 points
4 points
3 Points
2 Points
1 Point
Question &
• Questions were extremely
• Questions were all answered
• Questions are answered, but
• Team was nervous and
• Team was unprepared to
Answer
well-answered in a timely and
and responses were explained
in a somewhat roundabout
hesitated when answering
answer questions
Management
informed manner
and supported
way
questions
• Many questions were left
Possible 15 pts
• Answers were consistent
• Most members responded to
• Not all answers are
• Team had some difficulty
unanswered
with solutions
questions, some more so than
consistent with solutions
understanding questions
• Team members did not show
• Team members listened
others
• One or two team members
• Team rushed their answers
respect for one another during
X 3 =
closely, ensuring they fully
• Team members showed
responded to most questions
or left long pauses when trying
Q&A period
understood questions before
respect for one another and
• At times, team members
to answer
• Lack of confidence in
answering
restrain when allowing others
talked over one another or
• One or two team member
proposed solutions was
_________
• All team members
to speak
contradicted one another
dominated entire question
evident
15
responded to questions evenly
• Team stuck to the their
• For the most part, members
period
• Responses were significantly
• Team members did not
original solutions when
remained calm
• In many instances, team was
unbalanced amongst team
contradict one another
answering questions
unprepared to defend their
members
• Team members showed
• Team members did not
ideas
respect for one another in
appear flustered
• Significant differences
answering questions
between original proposed
• Team demonstrated
solutions and responses to
excellent ability to “think on
questions
their feet”
PowerPoint
• Slides were easy to read and
• Slides were easy to read and
• Slides were, at times, text
• Slides contained too much
• Slides contained many errors
Content
were free of errors
free of errors
heavy and potentially difficult
text and the order of slides did
• Order of slides was confusing
Possible 5 pts
• Slides were appropriate in
• Slides flowed in logical order
to read for some
not make sense
and disrupted the
terms of amount of text on
• Slides had appropriate
• A few minor errors were
• A few errors were noted
presentation
X 1 =
each one
content
noted on the slides
• Slides were visually
• Content on slides was poorly
• Content of slides was
• Content chosen for slides
unattractive (layout)
chosen and visually distracting
deliberate, well-chosen and
was appropriate but
• Difficult to read and
_________
helped to make key points
uninspiring and may or may
comprehend content
5
not have connected
appropriately to speaking
notes.
Grand Total
_________
100
HRC West Judging Template 2017
ADVERTISEMENT
0 votes
Related Articles
Related forms
Related Categories
Parent category: Miscellaneous