Synthesis Essay Peer Review Form (Page 2 of 2) in pdf

Synthesis Essay Peer Review Form Page 2

Did you circle yes for every answer without paying attention to the question?

Y or N Y or N

Is the tone on an academic level (check specific words and sentence structures)?

Y or N Y or N

Comments:

Attributions

Has the author provided adequate attribution?

Y or N Y or N

(“According to . . .” ; “As ________ asserts . . .”; etc.)

Were there any points that made you ask “Whose thought is this?”?

Y or N Y or N

Comments:

Formatting, length and citations

Has the author provided in-text citations for summaries, paraphrases and quotes?

Y or N Y or N

Are these citations correct?

Y or N Y or N

Is a Works Cited page provided?

Y or N Y or N

Is the Works Cited page correct?

Y or N Y or N

Is the essay at least 4 pages?

Y or N Y or N

Does the format follow MLA guidelines (margins, font, and heading)?

Y or N Y or N

Has the writer provided a fitting and catchy title?

Y or N Y or N

Comments:

Grammar, punctuation, spelling, etc.

Have you noticed any word-level or sentence level errors?

Y or N Y or N

If so, try to offer advice on how to correct these issues.

Has the writer used contractions or first or second person?

Y or N Y or N

If so, try to offer advice on how to change them.

Comments:

Overall, do you feel this writer has displayed good ethos, pathos and logos?

Y or N Y or N

Synthesis Essay Peer Review Form Page 2